ProCon.org

Under God in the Pledge

ProCon.org
Sign up free updates from ProCon.org RSS | add this Share | Email this page Email | Print this page Print
Under God in the Pledge Home
Sign up for free
email updates

Safeguarding Our Religious Liberties Act (HR 3190) Overview

I. Summary

Rep. Charles Pickering, Republican from Mississippi, introduced House Bill 3190, more commonly known as the Safeguarding Our Religious Liberties Act, on Sept. 25, 2003. It declared that among those powers reserved to the States and their political subdivisions are the powers to display the Ten Commandments, to recite the Pledge of Allegiance, and to recite the national motto on or within property owned or administered by them. It was submitted to the Committee on the Judiciary. On Oct. 22, 2003 it was referred to the House Subcommittee on the Constitution. It did not become law.

The Safeguarding Our Religious Liberties Act found, "the following:

(1) The Declaration of Independence declares that governments are instituted to secure certain unalienable rights, including life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, with which all human beings are endowed by their Creator and to which they are entitled by the laws of nature and of nature's God.

(2) The organic laws of the United States Code and the constitutions of every State, using various expressions, recognize God as the source of the blessings of liberty.

(3) The first amendment to the Constitution secures rights against laws respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof made by the Federal Government.

(4) The rights secured under the first amendment have been interpreted by the Federal courts to be included among the provisions of the 14th amendment.

(5) The 10th amendment reserves to the States, respectively, the powers not delegated to the Federal Government nor prohibited to the States.

(6) Disputes and doubts have arisen with respect to public displays of the Ten Commandments and to other public expression of religious faith.

(7) Section 5 of the 14th amendment grants Congress the power to enforce the provisions of the 14th amendment.

(8) Article III, section 2 of the Constitution grants Congress the authority to except certain matters from the jurisdiction of the Federal courts inferior to the Supreme Court.

SEC. 3. RELIGIOUS LIBERTY RIGHTS DECLARED.

(a) DISPLAY OF TEN COMMANDMENTS- The power to display the Ten Commandments on or within property owned or administered by the several States or political subdivisions of such States is among the powers reserved to the States, respectively.

(b) WORD `GOD' IN PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE - The power to recite the Pledge of Allegiance on or within property owned or administered by the several States or political subdivisions of such States is among the powers reserved to the States, respectively. The Pledge of Allegiance shall be, `I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with Liberty and justice for all.'.

(c) MOTTO `IN GOD WE TRUST'- The power to recite the national motto on or within property owned or administered by the several States or political subdivisions of such States is among the powers reserved to the States, respectively. The national motto shall be, `In God we trust'.

(d) EXERCISE OF CONGRESSIONAL POWER TO EXCEPT- The subject matter of subsections (a), (b), and (c) are excepted from the jurisdiction of Federal courts inferior to the Supreme Court."

See the full text of Safeguarding Our Religious Liberties Act (PDF) 36.5KB


II. Co-Sponsors
Representative's NameStatePartyDate of Co-Sponsorship
Todd AkinMORepublicanNov. 20, 2003
Spencer BachusALRepublicanOct. 17, 2003
James BarrettSCRepublicanNov. 6, 2003
Roscoe BartlettMDRepublicanOct. 28, 2003
Joe BartonTXRepublicanNov. 21, 2003
Bob BeauprezCORepublicanOct. 21, 2003
Rob BishopUTRepublicanNov. 19, 2003
Marsha BlackburnTNRepublicanJan. 20, 2004
Kevin BradyTXRepublicanNov. 20, 2003
John CarterTXRepublicanJan. 20, 2004
John CulbersonTXRepublicanJan. 23, 2004
Jo Ann DavisVARepublicanOct. 29, 2003
Nathan DealGARepublicanJan. 20, 2004
John DoolittleCARepublicanOct. 28, 2003
Terry EverettALRepublicanNov. 20, 2003
Trent FranksAZRepublicanOct. 30, 2003
John GingreyGARepublicanJan. 21, 2004
Virgil GoodeVARepublicanOct. 16, 2003
Samuel GravesMORepublicanOct. 28, 2003
Walter HergerCARepublicanNov. 20, 2003
Peter HoekstraMIRepublicanNov. 21, 2003
John HostettlerINRepublicanOct. 20, 2003
Samuel JohnsonTXRepublicanFeb. 10, 2004
Walter JonesNCRepublicanJan. 20, 2004
Ric KellerFLRepublicanNov. 21, 2003
Steve KingIARepublicanOct. 29, 2003

Representative's NameStatePartyDate of Co-Sponsorship
Jack KingstonGARepublicanOct. 29, 2003
Thomas LathamIARepublicanNov. 20, 2003
Thaddeus McCotterMIRepublicanNov. 19, 2003
John McHughNYRepublicanOct. 30, 2003
Jeff MillerFLRepublicanOct. 7, 2003
Marilyn MusgraveCORepublicanOct. 29, 2003
Charles NorwoodGARepublicanNov. 20, 2003
James NussleIARepublicanJune 8, 2004
Thomas OsborneNERepublicanNov. 21, 2003
C.L. OtterIDRepublicanJan. 20, 2004
Todd PlattsPARepublicanJan. 20, 2004
Nick RahallWVDemocratJan. 20, 2004
Michael RogersALRepublicanOct. 28, 2003
Jim RyunKSRepublicanJan. 21, 2004
John ShimkusILRepublicanOct. 28, 2003
Christopher SmithNJRepublicanMar. 17, 2004
Mark SouderINRepublicanOct. 30, 2003
John SullivanOKRepublicanJan. 28, 2004
Lee TerryNERepublicanOct. 1, 2003
Patrick TiberiOHRepublicanJan. 20, 2004
James TurnerTXDemocratNov. 20, 2003
David VitterLARepublicanJan. 20, 2004
Zach WampTNRepublicanOct. 8, 2003
Roger WickerMSRepublicanNov. 19, 2003
Addison WilsonSCRepublicanDec. 8, 2003
III. Related Links

1. Read the full text of Safeguarding Our Religious Liberties Act (DOC) 36.5KB

2. See similar legislation (Safeguarding Our Religious Liberties Act) introduced by Rep. Charles Pickering in the 109th Congress.

3. Examine similar Senate version - Religious Liberties Restoration Act.

4. Rep. Charles Pickering also introduced (House Joint Resolution 40) in the 108th Congress and (House Joint Resolution 108) and (House Joint Resolution 102) in the 107th Congress.

5. Research Congressional Actions on the Pledge of Allegiance.

6. Learn more about the First Amendment as it relates to the the Pledge of Allegiance.

7. Pledge of Allegiance History 1887-Today