ProCon.org

Under God in the Pledge

ProCon.org
Sign up free updates from ProCon.org RSS | add this Share | Email this page Email | Print this page Print
Under God in the Pledge Home
Sign up for free
email updates

Veterans' Memorials, Boy Scouts, Public Seals, and Other Public Expressions of Religion Protection Act of 2006 (HR 2679) Overview

I. Summary
II. Vote Summary
III. Geographic Chart of Votes
IV. Vote Totals by Representatives
V. Related Links
I. Summary

Rep. John Hostettler, Republican from Indiana, introduced the House Bill HR 2679 known as the Veterans' Memorials, Boy Scouts, Public Seals, and Other Public Expressions of Religion Protection Act of 2006 on May 26, 2005. It's text states it would "amend the Revised Statutes of the United States to prevent the use of the legal system in a manner that extorts money from State and local governments, and the Federal Government, and inhibits such governments' constitutional actions under the first, tenth, and fourteenth amendments." On Sept. 26, 2006 the bill passed the House of Representatives by roll call vote.

Veterans' Memorials, Boy Scouts, Public Seals, and Other Public Expressions of Religion Protection Act of 2006 stated, "(a) In General- Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a court shall not award reasonable fees and expenses of attorneys to the prevailing party on a claim of injury consisting of the violation of a prohibition in the Constitution against the establishment of religion brought against the United States or any agency or any official of the United States acting in his or her official capacity in any court having jurisdiction over such claim, and the remedies with respect to such a claim shall be limited to injunctive and declaratory relief.

(b) Definition- As used in this section, the term `a claim of injury consisting of the violation of a prohibition in the Constitution against the establishment of religion' includes, but is not limited to, a claim of injury resulting from-- [...]

3) the presence of religious words or imagery in the official seal of the United States and in its currency and official Pledge"

See the full text of Veterans' Memorials, Boy Scouts, Public Seals, and Other Public Expressions of Religion Protection Act of 2006 (PDF) 33KB

II. Vote Summary
HR 2679 passed the House of Representatives on Sept. 26, 2006 with:
Ayes Nays No Vote
  • 244 Ayes
  • Democrat 26 166 9
  • 173 Nays
  • Republican 218 6 6
  • 15 Not Voting
  • Independent 0 1 0
    III. Geographic Chart of Votes

    IV. Vote Totals

    A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z

     

    Representative's Name District Vote
    Abercrombie, Neil [D] HI-01 Nay
    Ackerman, Gary [D] NY-05 Nay
    Aderholt, Robert [R] AL-04 Aye
    Akin, W. [R] MO-02 Aye
    Alexander, Rodney [R] LA-05 Aye
    Allen, Thomas[D] ME-01 Nay
    Andrews, Robert [D] NJ-01 Nay
    Baca, Joe [D] CA-43 Nay
    Bachus, Spencer [R] AL-06 Aye
    Baird, Brian [D] WA-03 Nay
    Baker, Richard [R] LA-06 Aye
    Baldwin, Tammy [D] WI-02 Nay
    Barrett, James [R] SC-03 Aye
    Barrow, John [D] GA-12 Aye
    Bartlett, Roscoe [R] MD-06 Aye
    Barton, Joe [R] TX-06 Aye
    Bass, Charles [R] NH-02 Aye
    Bean, Melissa [D] IL-08 Nay
    Beauprez, Bob [R] CO-07 Aye
    Becerra, Xavier [D] CA-31 Nay
    Berkley, Shelley [D] NV-01 Nay
    Berman, Howard [D] CA-28 Nay
    Berry, Robert [D] AR-01 Aye
    Biggert, Judy [R] IL-13 Nay
    Bilbray, Brian [R] CA-50 Aye
    Bilirakis, Michael [R] FL-09 Aye
    Bishop, Rob [R] UT-01 Aye
    Bishop, Sanford [D] GA-02 Nay
    Bishop, Timothy [D] NY-01 Nay
    Blackburn, Marsha [R] TN-07 Aye
    Blumenauer, Earl [D] OR-03 Nay
    Blunt, Roy [R] MO-07 Aye
    Boehlert, Sherwood [R] NY-24 Nay
    Boehner, John [R] OH-08 Aye
    Bonilla, Henry [R] TX-23 Aye
    Bonner, Jo [R] AL-01 Aye
    Bono, Mary [R] CA-45 Aye
    Boozman, John [R] AR-03 Aye
    Boren, Dan [D] OK-02 Aye
    Boswell, Leonard [D] IA-03 Nay
    Boucher, Frederick [D] VA-09 Nay
    Boustany, Charles [R] LA-07 Aye
    Boyd, F. [D] FL-02 Aye
    Brady, Kevin [R] TX-08 Aye
    Brady, Robert [D] PA-01 Nay
    Brown, Corrine [D] FL-03 Nay
    Brown, Henry [R] SC-01 Aye
    Brown, Sherrod [D] OH-13 No Vote
    Brown-Waite, Virginia [R] FL-05 Aye
    Burgess, Michael [R] TX-26 Aye
    Burton, Dan [R] IN-05 Aye
    Butterfield, George [D] NC-01 Nay
    Buyer, Stephen [R] IN-04 Aye
    Calvert, Ken [R] CA-44 Aye
    Camp, David [R] MI-04 Aye
    Campbell, John [R] CA-48 Aye
    Cannon, Christopher [R] UT-03 Aye
    Cantor, Eric [R] VA-07 Aye
    Capito, Shelley [R] WV-02 Aye
    Capps, Lois [D] CA-23 Nay
    Capuano, Michael [D] MA-08 Nay
    Cardin, Benjamin [D] MD-03 Nay
    Cardoza, Dennis [D] CA-18 Aye
    Carnahan, Russ [D] MO-03 Nay
    Carson, Julia [D] IN-07 Nay
    Carter, John [R] TX-31 Aye
    Case, Ed [D] HI-02 Nay
    Castle, Michael [R] DE-00 No Vote
    Chabot, Steven [R] OH-01 Aye
    Chandler, Ben [D] KY-06 Nay
    Chocola, Chris [R] IN-02 Aye
    Clay, William [D] MO-01 Nay
    Cleaver, Emanuel [D] MO-05 Nay
    Clyburn, James [D] SC-06 Nay
    Coble, John [R] NC-06 Aye
    Cole, Tom [R] OK-04 Aye
    Conaway, K. [R] TX-11 Aye
    Conyers, John [D] MI-14 Nay
    Cooper, Jim [D] TN-05 Nay
    Costa, Jim [D] CA-20 Aye
    Costello, Jerry [D] IL-12 Nay
    Cramer, Robert [D] AL-05 Aye
    Crenshaw, Ander [R] FL-04 Aye
    Crowley, Joseph [D] NY-07 Nay
    Cubin, Barbara [R] WY-00 Aye
    Cuellar, Henry [D] TX-28 Aye
    Culberson, John [R] TX-07 Aye
    Cummings, Elijah [D] MD-07 Nay
    Davis, Artur [D] AL-07 Nay
    Davis, Danny [D] IL-07 Nay
    Davis, Geoff [R] KY-04 Aye
    Davis, James [D] FL-11 No Vote
    Davis, Jo Ann [R] VA-01 Aye
    Davis, Lincoln [D] TN-04 Aye
    Davis, Susan [D] CA-53 Nay
    Davis, Thomas [R] VA-11 Aye
    Deal, Nathan [R] GA-10 Aye
    DeFazio, Peter [D] OR-04 Nay
    DeGette, Diana [D] CO-01 Nay
    Delahunt, William [D] MA-10 Nay
    DeLauro, Rosa [D] CT-03 Nay
    Dent, Charles [R] PA-15 Aye
    Diaz-Balart, Lincoln [R] FL-21 Aye
    Diaz-Balart, Mario [R] FL-25 Aye
    Dicks, Norman [D] WA-06 Nay
    Dingell, John [D] MI-15 Nay
    Doggett, Lloyd [D] TX-25 Nay
    Doolittle, John [R] CA-04 Aye
    Doyle, Michael [D] PA-14 Nay
    Drake, Thelma [R] VA-02 Aye
    Dreier, David [R] CA-26 Aye
    Duncan, John [R] TN-02 Aye
    Edwards, Thomas [D] TX-17 Nay
    Ehlers, Vernon [R] MI-03 Aye
    Emanuel, Rahm [D] IL-05 Nay
    Emerson, Jo Ann [R] MO-08 Aye
    Engel, Eliot [D] NY-17 Nay
    English, Philip [R] PA-03 Aye
    Eshoo, Anna [D] CA-14 Nay
    Etheridge, Bob [D] NC-02 Nay
    Evans, Lane [D] IL-17 No Vote
    Everett, Terry [R] AL-02 Aye
    Farr, Sam [D] CA-17 Nay
    Fattah, Chaka [D] PA-02 Nay
    Feeney, Tom [R] FL-24 Aye
    Ferguson, Michael [R] NJ-07 Aye
    Filner, Bob [D] CA-51 Nay
    Fitzpatrick, Michael [R] PA-08 Aye
    Flake, Jeff [R] AZ-06 Aye
    Foley, Mark [R] FL-16 Aye
    Forbes, James [R] VA-04 Aye
    Ford, Harold [D] TN-09 No Vote
    Fortenberry, Jeffrey [R] NE-01 Aye
    Fossella, Vito [R] NY-13 Aye
    Foxx, Virginia [R] NC-05 Aye
    Frank, Barney [D] MA-04 Nay
    Franks, Trent [R] AZ-02 Aye
    Frelinghuysen, Rodney [R] NJ-11 Aye
    Gallegly, Elton [R] CA-24 Aye
    Garrett, E. [R] NJ-05 Aye
    Gerlach, Jim [R] PA-06 Aye
    Gibbons, James [R] NV-02 Aye
    Gilchrest, Wayne [R] MD-01 Nay
    Gillmor, Paul [R] OH-05 Aye
    Gingrey, John [R] GA-11 Aye
    Gohmert, Louis [R] TX-01 Aye
    Gonzalez, Charles [D] TX-20 Nay
    Goode, Virgil [R] VA-05 Aye
    Goodlatte, Robert [R] VA-06 Aye
    Gordon, Barton [D] TN-06 Aye
    Granger, Kay [R] TX-12 Aye
    Graves, Samuel [R] MO-06 Aye
    Green, Al [D] TX-09 Nay
    Green, Mark [R] WI-08 No Vote
    Green, Raymond [D] TX-29 Nay
    Grijalva, Raul [D] AZ-07 Nay
    Gutierrez, Luis [D] IL-04 Nay
    Gutknecht, Gilbert [R] MN-01 Aye
    Hall, Ralph [R] TX-04 Aye
    Harman, Jane [D] CA-36 Nay
    Harris, Katherine [R] FL-13 Aye
    Hart, Melissa [R] PA-04 Aye
    Hastings, Alcee [D] FL-23 Nay
    Hastings, Doc [R] WA-04 Aye
    Hayes, Robert [R] NC-08 Aye
    Hayworth, John [R] AZ-05 Aye
    Hefley, Joel [R] CO-05 Aye
    Hensarling, Jeb [R] TX-05 Aye
    Herger, Walter [R] CA-02 Aye
    Herseth, Stephanie [D] SD-0 Aye
    Higgins, Brian [D] NY-27 Nay
    Hinchey, Maurice [D] NY-22 Nay
    Hinojosa, Ruben [D] TX-15 Aye
    Hobson, David [R] OH-07 Aye
    Hoekstra, Peter [R] MI-02 Aye
    Holden, Tim [D] PA-17 Nay
    Holt, Rush [D] NJ-12 Nay
    Honda, Michael [D] CA-15 Nay
    Hooley, Darlene [D] OR-05 Nay
    Hostettler, John [R] IN-08 Aye
    Hoyer, Steny [D] MD-05 Nay
    Hulshof, Kenny [R] MO-09 Aye
    Hunter, Duncan [R] CA-52 Aye
    Hyde, Henry [R] IL-06 Aye
    Inglis, Bob [R] SC-04 Aye
    Inslee, Jay [D] WA-01 Nay
    Israel, Steve [D] NY-02 Nay
    Issa, Darrell [R] CA-49 Aye
    Istook, Ernest [R] OK-05 No Vote
    Jackson, Jesse [D] IL-02 Nay
    Jackson-Lee, Sheila [D] TX-18 Nay
    Jefferson, William [D] LA-02 No Vote
    Jenkins, William [R] TN-01 Aye
    Jindal, Bobby [R] LA-01 Aye
    Johnson, Eddie [D] TX-30 Nay
    Johnson, Nancy [R] CT-05 Aye
    Johnson, Samuel [R] TX-03 Aye
    Johnson, Timothy [R] IL-15 Aye
    Jones, Stephanie [D] OH-11 Nay
    Jones, Walter [R] NC-03 Aye
    Kanjorski, Paul [D] PA-11 Nay
    Kaptur, Marcy [D] OH-09 Nay
    Keller, Ric [R] FL-08 Aye
    Kelly, Sue [R] NY-19 Aye
    Kennedy, Mark [R] MN-06 Aye
    Kennedy, Patrick [D] RI-01 Nay
    Kildee, Dale [D] MI-05 Nay
    Kilpatrick, Carolyn [D] MI-13 Nay
    Kind, Ronald [D] WI-03 Nay
    King, Peter [R] NY-03 Aye
    King, Steve [R] IA-05 Aye
    Kingston, Jack [R] GA-01 Aye
    Kirk, Mark [R] IL-10 Nay
    Kline, John [R] MN-02 Aye
    Knollenberg, Joseph [R] MI-09 Aye
    Kolbe, James [R] AZ-08 Aye
    Kucinich, Dennis [D] OH-10 Nay
    Kuhl, John [R] NY-29 Aye
    Representative's Name District Vote
    LaHood, Ray [R] IL-18 Aye
    Langevin, James [D] RI-02 Nay
    Lantos, Tom [D] CA-12 Nay
    Larsen, Rick [D] WA-02 Nay
    Larson, John [D] CT-01 Nay
    Latham, Thomas [R] IA-04 Aye
    LaTourette, Steven [R] OH-14 Aye
    Leach, James [R] IA-02 Aye
    Lee, Barbara [D] CA-09 Nay
    Levin, Sander [D] MI-12 Nay
    Lewis, Jerry [R] CA-41 Aye
    Lewis, John [D] GA-05 No Vote
    Lewis, Ron [R] KY-02 Aye
    Linder, John [R] GA-07 Aye
    Lipinski, Daniel [D] IL-03 Aye
    LoBiondo, Frank [R] NJ-02 Aye
    Lofgren, Zoe [D] CA-16 Nay
    Lowey, Nita [D] NY-18 Nay
    Lucas, Frank [R] OK-03 Aye
    Lungren, Daniel [R] CA-03 Aye
    Lynch, Stephen [D] MA-09 Nay
    Mack, Connie [R] FL-14 Aye
    Maloney, Carolyn [D] NY-14 Nay
    Manzullo, Donald [R] IL-16 Aye
    Marchant, Kenny [R] TX-24 Aye
    Markey, Edward [D] MA-07 Nay
    Marshall, James [D] GA-03 Aye
    Matheson, Jim [D] UT-02 Aye
    Matsui, Doris [D] CA-05 Nay
    McCarthy, Carolyn [D] NY-04 Nay
    McCaul, Michael [R] TX-10 Aye
    McCollum, Betty [D] MN-04 Nay
    McCotter, Thaddeus [R] MI-11 Aye
    McCrery, James [R] LA-04 Aye
    McDermott, James [D] WA-07 Nay
    McGovern, James [D] MA-03 Nay
    McHenry, Patrick [R] NC-10 Aye
    McHugh, John [R] NY-23 Aye
    McIntyre, Mike [D] NC-07 Aye
    McKeon, Howard [R] CA-25 Aye
    McKinney, Cynthia [D] GA-04 Nay
    Mcmorris, Cathy [R] WA-05 Aye
    McNulty, Michael [D] NY-21 Nay
    Meehan, Martin [D] MA-05 No Vote
    Meek, Kendrick [D] FL-17 Nay
    Meeks, Gregory [D] NY-06 Nay
    Melancon, Charles [D] LA-03 Aye
    Mica, John [R] FL-07 Aye
    Michaud, Michael [D] ME-02 Nay
    Millender-McDonald, Juanita [D] CA-37 No Vote
    Miller, Candice [R] MI-10 Nay
    Miller, Gary [R] CA-42 Aye
    Miller, George [D] CA-07 Nay
    Miller, Jeff [R] FL-01 Aye
    Miller, R. [D] NC-13 Nay
    Mollohan, Alan [D] WV-01 Nay
    Moore, Dennis [D] KS-03 Nay
    Moore, Gwen [D] WI-04 Nay
    Moran, James [D] VA-08 Nay
    Moran, Jerry [R] KS-01 Aye
    Murphy, Tim [R] PA-18 Aye
    Murtha, John [D] PA-12 Nay
    Musgrave, Marilyn [R] CO-04 Aye
    Myrick, Sue [R] NC-09 Aye
    Nadler, Jerrold [D] NY-08 Nay
    Napolitano, Grace [D] CA-38 Nay
    Neal, Richard [D] MA-02 Nay
    Neugebauer, Randy [R] TX-19 Aye
    Ney, Robert [R] OH-18 No Vote
    Northup, Anne [R] KY-03 Aye
    Norwood, Charles [R] GA-09 Aye
    Nunes, Devin [R] CA-21 Aye
    Nussle, James [R] IA-01 No Vote
    Oberstar, James [D] MN-08 Nay
    Obey, David [D] WI-07 Nay
    Olver, John [D] MA-01 Nay
    Ortiz, Solomon [D] TX-27 Aye
    Osborne, Thomas [R] NE-03 Aye
    Otter, C.L. [R] ID-01 Aye
    Owens, Major [D] NY-11 Nay
    Oxley, Michael [R] OH-04 Aye
    Pallone, Frank [D] NJ-06 Nay
    Pascrell, William [D] NJ-08 Nay
    Pastor, Edward [D] AZ-04 Nay
    Paul, Ronald [R] TX-14 Aye
    Payne, Donald [D] NJ-10 Nay
    Pearce, Steven [R] NM-02 Aye
    Pelosi, Nancy [D] CA-08 Nay
    Pence, Mike [R] IN-06 Aye
    Peterson, Collin [D] MN-07 Aye
    Peterson, John [R] PA-05 Aye
    Petri, Thomas [R] WI-06 Aye
    Pickering, Charles [R] MS-03 Aye
    Pitts, Joseph [R] PA-16 Aye
    Platts, Todd [R] PA-19 Aye
    Poe, Ted [R] TX-02 Aye
    Pombo, Richard [R] CA-11 No Vote
    Pomeroy, Earl [D] ND-00 Nay
    Porter, Jon [R] NV-03 Aye
    Price, David [D] NC-04 Nay
    Price, Tom [R] GA-06 Aye
    Pryce, Deborah [R] OH-15 Aye
    Putnam, Adam [R] FL-12 Aye
    Radanovich, George [R] CA-19 Aye
    Rahall, Nick [D] WV-03 Aye
    Ramstad, James [R] MN-03 Aye
    Rangel, Charles [D] NY-15 Nay
    Regula, Ralph [R] OH-16 Aye
    Rehberg, Dennis [R] MT-00 Aye
    Reichert, Dave [R] WA-08 Aye
    Renzi, Rick [R] AZ-01 Aye
    Reyes, Silvestre [D] TX-16 Nay
    Reynolds, Thomas [R] NY-26 Aye
    Rogers, Harold [R] KY-05 Aye
    Rogers, Michael [R] AL-03 Aye
    Rogers, Michael [R] MI-8 Aye
    Rohrabacher, Dana [R] CA-46 Aye
    Ros-Lehtinen, Ileana [R] FL-18 Aye
    Ross, Mike [D] AR-04 Aye
    Rothman, Steven [D] NJ-09 Nay
    Roybal-Allard, Lucille [D] CA-34 Nay
    Royce, Edward [R] CA-40 Aye
    Ruppersberger, C.A. [D] MD-02 Nay
    Rush, Bobby [D] IL-01 Nay
    Ryan, Paul [R] WI-01 Aye
    Ryan, Timothy [D] OH-17 Nay
    Ryun, Jim [R] KS-02 Aye
    Sabo, Martin [D] MN-05 Nay
    Salazar, John [D] CO-03 Aye
    Sanchez, Linda [D] CA-39 Nay
    Sanchez, Loretta [D] CA-47 Nay
    Sanders, Bernard [I] VT-00 Nay
    Saxton, H. [R] NJ-03 Aye
    Schakowsky, Janice [D] IL-09 Nay
    Schiff, Adam [D] CA-29 Nay
    Schmidt, Jean [R] OH-02 Aye
    Schwartz, Allyson [D] PA-13 Nay
    Schwarz, John [R] MI-07 Aye
    Scott, David [D] GA-13 Aye
    Scott, Robert [D] VA-03 Nay
    Sensenbrenner, F. [R] WI-05 Aye
    Serrano, José [D] NY-16 Nay
    Sessions, Peter [R] TX-32 Aye
    Shadegg, John [R] AZ-03 Aye
    Shaw, E. [R] FL-22 Aye
    Shays, Christopher [R] CT-04 Nay
    Sherman, Brad [D] CA-27 Nay
    Sherwood, Donald [R] PA-10 Aye
    Shimkus, John [R] IL-19 Aye
    Shuster, William [R] PA-09 Aye
    Simmons, Robert [R] CT-02 Aye
    Simpson, Michael [R] ID-02 Aye
    Skelton, Ike [D] MO-04 Aye
    Slaughter, Louise [D] NY-28 Nay
    Smith, Adam [D] WA-09 Nay
    Smith, Christopher [R] NJ-04 Aye
    Smith, Lamar [R] TX-21 Aye
    Snyder, Victor [D] AR-02 Nay
    Sodrel, Michael [R] IN-09 Aye
    Solis, Hilda [D] CA-32 Nay
    Souder, Mark [R] IN-03 Aye
    Spratt, John [D] SC-05 Aye
    Stark, Fortney [D] CA-13 Nay
    Stearns, Clifford [R] FL-06 Aye
    Strickland, Ted [D] OH-06 No Vote
    Stupak, Bart [D] MI-01 Nay
    Sullivan, John [R] OK-01 Aye
    Sweeney, John [R] NY-20 Aye
    Tancredo, Thomas [R] CO-06 Aye
    Tanner, John [D] TN-08 Nay
    Tauscher, Ellen [D] CA-10 Nay
    Taylor, Charles [R] NC-11 Aye
    Taylor, Gene [D] MS-04 Aye
    Terry, Lee [R] NE-02 Aye
    Thomas, William [R] CA-22 Aye
    Thompson, Bennie [D] MS-02 Nay
    Thompson, C. [D] CA-01 Nay
    Thornberry, William [R] TX-13 Aye
    Tiahrt, Todd [R] KS-04 Aye
    Tiberi, Patrick [R] OH-12 Aye
    Tierney, John [D] MA-06 Nay
    Towns, Edolphus [D] NY-10 Nay
    Turner, Michael [R] OH-03 Aye
    Udall, Mark [D] CO-02 Nay
    Udall, Tom [D] NM-03 Nay
    Upton, Frederick [R] MI-06 Aye
    Van Hollen, Christopher [D] MD-08 Nay
    Velazquez, Nydia [D] NY-12 Nay
    Visclosky, Peter [D] IN-01 Nay
    Walden, Greg [R] OR-02 Aye
    Walsh, James [R] NY-25 Aye
    Wamp, Zach [R] TN-03 Aye
    Wasserman Schultz, Debbie [D] FL-20 Nay
    Waters, Maxine [D] CA-35 Nay
    Watson, Diane [D] CA-33 Nay
    Watt, Melvin [D] NC-12 Nay
    Waxman, Henry [D] CA-30 Nay
    Weiner, Anthony [D] NY-09 Nay
    Weldon, David [R] FL-15 Aye
    Weldon, W. [R] PA-07 Aye
    Weller, Gerald [R] IL-11 Aye
    Westmoreland, Lynn [R] GA-08 Aye
    Wexler, Robert [D] FL-19 Nay
    Whitfield, Edward [R] KY-01 Aye
    Wicker, Roger [R] MS-01 Aye
    Wilson, Addison [R] SC-02 Aye
    Wilson, Heather [R] NM-01 Aye
    Wolf, Frank [R] VA-10 Aye
    Woolsey, Lynn [D] CA-06 Nay
    Wu, David [D] OR-01 Nay
    Wynn, Albert [D] MD-04 Nay
    Young, C. W. [R] FL-10 Aye
    Young, Donald [R] AK-00 Aye
    V. Related Links

    1. See the full text of HR 2679. (PDF) 33KB

    2. Research the Congressional Actions on the Pledge of Allegiance.

    3. Pledge of Allegiance History 1887-Today